WALL*E: a review (JimK & DonnaK)
By JimK




(7 votes)
Related Entries
Halloween Post: Fridge Fright
To boldly expand the universe
On crapping where you eat
Sam Raimi to direct World of Warcraft movie
Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
I’ve been trying to find someone to go see this with for a bit and I’ve yet to have any luck. I’m thinking I may just go by myself but I’d rather not if I can help it.
I hear you…I don’t tend to go to movies alone, but Donna does.
Honestly, this one is so much fun and so heartwarming it could make me go alone for a second viewing.
I generally don’t mind going to a movie by myself now and then. There’s just something about going to see what most people will consider a ‘kids’ movie that’s kinda stuck in my head at the moment. To clarify, a grown man by himself to see a movie surrounded by a bunch of kids, maybe a bit silly but it’s stuck in there and it aint going away.
Ummm… Spoiler warnings? I mean, it’s not the world’s most epic plot or anything, but still….
No, you’re right, I just completely forgot to add that at the beginning. SORRY!
we adored it. i cried. i giggled my ass off. i wanted to beat the kid behind me:
mom: stop talking
kid: but i WANNA talk
(i swear, thats how it went down)
i also laughed my ass off at the short. always love pixar shorts.
yeah. totally 2 thumbs way the fuck up.
Glad you guys enjoyed it. Of course, some soulless political jagoffs are whining about it. If that doesn’t prove just how empty they are, I don’t know what will.
Your review is insightful, but I like mine better:
Awesome. Awesome. Awesome.
Straight to the point. ^.^`
Went to see it monday. Enjoyed it very much. Me and my date were expecting a shit ton of kids as well but the only other people in the theater were people in their 20s and 30s. Definently looking forward to seeing it again when it hits DVD. I really didn’t think Pixar could’ve matched The Incredibles but I think this one came really close. The scene with EVE watching her own surveilance videos really did it for me.
I caught the movie at the latest time possible when I saw it. So few, if any, kids were there and if they were they were appropriately quiet.
Though before it they had the preview for that Chihuahua movie. How I’d love to beat the head in of the person who thought of that movie.
Yup. You won. I loved this movie beyond words. I really, truly did.
HAHAHA, victory.
I believe one of the reviews I read of the movie said that they actually watched Chaplin movies during lunch while making this movie.
I did love all the little sci-fi tributes and jokes thrown in. Such as the cockroach being the only living thing as well as the perfectly preserved twinkies. You’ve got Sputnik thrown in there, and probably a half dozen other things that I missed.
I think Rann mentioned how he didn’t like Wall-E’s head just being giant emotive eyes that are there to give sympathy to Wall-e in another thread. But for me it wasn’t so much the eyes. Yes they helped in conveying some of the emotion but it was only one part. The sounds he makes and his actions and mannerisms did more to convey emotion than just the eyes. I never really felt sorry or sympathetic to Wall-e either. I just liked him, and I think part of it was because they weren’t going out there with the idea of “here’s this poor lonely robot that looks sad, like him!” It never felt like they were forcing it.
And if you haven’t watched the little clips of him playing with things like the hula hoop and the vaccuum cleaner, you need to.
Though before it they had the preview for that Chihuahua movie. How I’d love to beat the head in of the person who thought of that movie.
Agreed. Man do I feel sorry for parents who regularly have to take their kids to the children’s movies and sit through 5 trailers of more bad movies their kids will want to see. There was another animated one about flies traveling to the moon during the Apollo missions.
Is this the kind of movie that you “Have” to see in the theater or will it be better to own it on Blu Ray and enjoy it from the comfort of your own home???????
Is this the kind of movie that you “Have” to see in the theater or will it be better to own it on Blu Ray and enjoy it from the comfort of your own home???????
Well…if you have a massive, high-quality TV and kick-ass sound, then you will probably be satisfied with @home on blu. BUT…it really is glorious and beautiful on a big screen. Plus you get the nifty short in the theater.
Try a late, mid-week showing for less kids and people. Although I will say, at our local, EVERY child shut their mouths about 4 seconds in and never made an inappropriate peep. They were transfixed by WALL*E.
spivey,
I think that if you look at comments Donna made before watching the movie and her last part of the review after showing a picture of wall-e and eve shows that anyone who watched the movie probably can’t give an unbiased opinion whether to see it in theater or wait for the dvd.



JimK: What can we say about Wall*E that you haven’t already read? Well, one or two things maybe.
SPOILER WARNINGS (added…sorry I forgot!) SPOILER WARNINGS!
Quick summary for those who live under rocks: Wall*E is a Waste Allocation Load Lifter, Earth class. He’s the last of a fleet of robots designed to clean up the mountains of trash covering the Earth. Humanity just kept buying and building and disposing and one day the Earth just got full. Towards the end, some rich folks took a pleasure cruise (read: lifeboat the hell out of here!) in the world’s first luxury space-liner. They never came home. The only things left on the planet after 700 years or so are WALL*E, a cockroach, Twinkies, and a whole lot of fucking garbage.
WALL*E goes about his business, making blocks out of piles of trash. Over the centuries he’s become obsessed with certain aspects of humanity. Lighters. Rubik’s Cubes. A hubcap. A videotape of an old romantic musical. Anything that catches his eye, he keeps. Including the first green plant to sprout in 700+ years. Along comes a ship one day and deposits EVE, an Extraterrestrial Vegetation Evaluator, and WALL*E is in love immediately. He tries to impress her with his collection. When he shows her the plant, she puts it inside her shell and shuts down.
Eventually a ship comes to collect EVE, WALL*E stows away (on the outside!) and we meet up with what is left of humanity. Humans are all too fat, lazy and slothful to do jack for themselves. All these centuries of lowered gravity has reduced bone density and a life of non-stop consumerism from dusk till dawn has increased their mass. Every need is attended to by automated helpers.
EVE tries to deliver the plant according to her directive. It is supposed to trigger a return to Earth, but the Autopilot doesn’t let that happen. He’s following the last orders received by the President (Of the US and Buy-N-Large). The Earth is toxic, don’t come home.
Struggle ensues. Lessons are learned, Heroes are made. Happy endings all around.
DonnaK: I feel I have to start this off with an admission. I really, REALLY dislike animated movies.
There. I’ve confessed. I hate animation. I really have no rational or logical reason for how I feel nor can I explain it. I just don’t seem to *connect* with animated films. To be perfectly blunt, they tend to both bore and annoy me in equal measure. The last animated feature I can honestly say I enjoyed is The Lion King. Since then… meh. I saw Toy Story, Antz, A Bug’s Life… and then just gave up watching them. It’s just not my thing. But yet here’s this animated film that’s got the world buzzing and my husband is desperate to review it. So I had to go into WALL*E with as open a mind as possible, put aside my prejudices against animated features and try to give the most honest appraisal that I could.
JimK: I so had to talk her into this. And she griped daily about having to do it, too. Ha! I win.
DonnaK: Yup. You won. I loved this movie beyond words. I really, truly did. I thought it was touching, beautiful, magical, and full to the brim with love. Against any previously conceived notions I had, I was well and truly moved by WALL*E. This is a brilliant love story that really transcended the medium for me. I felt the love between WALL*E and EVE as fully as I would have had they been real beings. I laughed, I gasped, I cried like a baby. I didn’t believe people when they said how rich and full of emotion this movie was, and I was so very wrong. Watching WALL*E renewed my spirit and uplifted me. I am honestly grateful now to Jim for making me watch this film. Had he not done so I probably never would have seen it and I would be a lesser person for having missed such a heartwarming and gorgeous film.
JimK: The bottom line with this movie is, it is one of the most adorable things you will ever watch. It’s achingly, ridiculously, impossibly cute. WALL*E is Charlie Chaplin for the first half hour, just silently roaming around doing his thing, a bit of a bumbler, given to hilariously cute pratfalls and a wonderful relationship with the only living thing on Earth, his friend the cockroach. Watching him fall in love with EVE is touching, adorable and heart-warming. Watching his single-minded devotion to her, which ultimately means helping her fulfill her directive, was the most romantic thing I have watched in ages.
If you don’t love this movie, then there is something broken inside you and I suggest you seek therapy immediately.
DonnaK: Yes, yes and yes again. I think the thing that really struck me the most about WALL*E is that, at its heart, it really *is* a Chaplin film. WALL*E made for a delightful Tramp who bumbled and stumbled his way into the heart of the woman of his dreams. Turning the story into a Chaplin-esqe film is what in my mind made this film truly transcendent. It was a stroke of genius that turned the very cold and unforgiving world of the movie into something grander that felt both familiar and close to the heart. If I had any criticism of WALL*E it would be that I wished we had had more time on Earth and thus more “Tramp” time between WALL*E and EVE. Once the pair reached the spaceship the film took a detour towards a more Three Stooges style which I found less endearing but nevertheless effective.
JimK: At multiple times during the first half, I found myself thinking of WALL*E not only as Chaplin, but also as Johnny Depp in Benny & Joon and of course, RDJ as Chaplin himself. Not just because of the mechanics of the comedic movements…but because of how they made me feel. Somehow Pixar imbued this little robot with a soul. I feel, like millions of other people who watched it, like I connected with him somehow.
DonnaK: I couldn’t agree with you more. I really don’t have any real criticisms of WALL*E, and that’s a rare thing for me to say. I know many people are upset about perceived political or social overtones in the film, but I really don’t get that in the slightest. Yes, WALL*E had some moral lessons, but what animated feature doesn’t? For me, the central and overriding message of the film was very simple. Love and be loved. Enjoy life and love as much and as deeply as you can. Embrace love of life, others, and your world and you will be happy. How could anyone be offended by that?
JimK: The second half does turn into an adventure/Stooges-style movie with lessons about duty, about fulfilling your destiny, about knowing when to say no and do things your own way…none of it is too over the top and none of it is anywhere near the level of “preachiness” I expected based on buzz. Here is where I am going to slightly break a rule here at MOA. That rule is “NO POLITICS.”
Unfortunately, we have to talk politics for just a second. Most of the objections I have seen to this movie - the vociferous ones - are based on the idea that it is a somewhat Greenpeace-y, global-warming-is-gonna-kill-us-all movie that berates anyone who isn’t a granola-crunching hippie. That is, in short, utter bullshit. This movie is no more preachy than any other Disney classic. Bambi was preachy. Shit, Fantasia is preachy! WALL*E preaches some really good, and really worthwhile, ideals without beating you in the face with them. Love someone completely. Clean up your room. Do your duty, but do it with some flair and originality. Once in a blue moon, the system needs bucking, Pick your moments.
How are these bad messages, no matter what your politics are? I put it to the world; if your panties are in a bunch over this movie, then you are dead inside and should never, EVER talk to people. You should sit in a room, alone, and complain at your walls because you have some serious problems. Humanity didn’t destroy the earth because we created greenhouse gas or ate meat or drove Hummers. Humans made too much garbage. Look at your curb next trash day. Can you really tell me you feel comfortable with that pile? Too. Much. Garbage. On top of that, the humans in the movie looked to the robots to do everything for them. They brushed people’s teeth, wiped their asses, everything. So, in addition to the message that “Hey, maybe, if it’s not a huge deal, we could all create a little less garbage?” we also got the message that you cannot and should not look to someone else to fulfill your every need, want and desire. Complacency and survival alone are not the same as being alive.
These are all great messages that I hope we all agree should be taught to our children. Hell, to most of our adults as well. And that’s me off my soapbox.
DonnaK: You know what? I couldn’t have said that any better if I tried. So I’m not even going to. I agree with everything Jim said, and that’s enough politics for me as well. On to the ratings!
I’m giving WALL*E a solid five star rating with a very strong recommendation to see. I loved this film far more than I ever thought I would or could, and if it could touch a hardened heart like mine it will positively melt yours. It was a brilliant film that I feel should be required viewing for everyone. Bravo, Pixar - you’ve created a masterpiece that I think will live forever.
JimK: If I could give it twenty stars I would. Needless to say, five stars from me with a “If you don’t see this movie, JimK might come to your house and slap you in the mouth” recommendation.
Everyone should go and enjoy this magical, mesmerizing and romantic movie about a plucky little robot and his sexy girlfriend who save the world. I think you’re right, Donna, this is one of those special movies that will live on and on and on.
One other thing: We both loved that Pixar gave us a short before the feature started. MORE OF THAT PLEASE! I wish we always had a little short, even before live action movies. How great would it be to see a whole industry of little 5-7 minute movies in theaters? Get on that, Hollywood.
DonnaK: AWWWW!!!! My gods, people? How can you not love that? GO SEE THIS MOVIE RIGHT NOW!!!!
07/9/2008 9:05 PM
Categories: Movies
Tags: walle